How to Build a Business Case for a First-Generation MSP

BLOGBy Rullion on 08 September 2025

When you’re managing large numbers of project-based contractors or temporary staff, the idea of a Managed Service Programme (MSP) often comes into the conversation. An MSP can centralise contingent workforce management, helping to improve visibility of spend, streamline compliance, and ultimately make hiring more efficient and strategic. But if your business is considering its first-generation MSP, the challenge often isn’t the programme itself; it’s building a strong, evidence-based business case that gains buy-in from internal stakeholders.

A first-generation MSP is a managed service programme introduced into a business for the very first time. It usually replaces manual processes and scattered supplier arrangements with a centralised, consistent, and strategic way of managing your contingent workforce.

How to build a business case for an MSP

At Rullion, our MSP consultants have had exposure to all levels of talent consultancy surrounding MSP and have put together this helpful guide to walk you through how to structure that business case, the benefits you should highlight, and how to present ROI in a way that draws in your decision-makers.

1. Define the problem

Before you start providing an MSP as the solution, start with the “why”. Begin by clearly defining the workforce challenges your organisation faces today:

  • Limited visibility of contingent workforce spend

  • Fragmented supplier management and inconsistent quality

  • Compliance risks with IR35 or worker classification

  • Escalating costs with little ability to forecast or control

  • Hiring managers spending too much time on recruitment admin

Where possible, quantifying the scale of these challenges (e.g., percentage overspend, average time-to-hire, compliance audit findings) helps show why the current model isn’t sustainable.

 

2. Identify stakeholders and their priorities

Different decision-makers will view an MSP through different lenses. A strong business case addresses each of these perspectives, showing how an MSP aligns with their objectives.

  • Finance leaders want cost savings, forecasting accuracy, and spend control.

  • HR leaders want improved candidate quality, DEI alignment, and workforce planning.

  • Procurement leads want supplier consolidation, stronger negotiation leverage, and compliance.

  • Hiring managers want faster, simpler access to talent.

 

3. Establish the baseline data

To justify investment, you need a starting benchmark of how things operate today. Even if the data isn’t perfect, presenting a baseline gives stakeholders a clear “before” picture against which future improvements can be measured. Collect data on:

  • Current headcount of contingent workers (by department/region)

  • Total annual spend on contractors and temps

  • Average cost-per-hire and time-to-hire

  • Number of suppliers and volume of hires per supplier

  • Compliance or audit findings

4. Showcase the potential benefits of an MSP

Translate MSP as a solution into tangible outcomes that matter to your business. And, rather than listing them in the abstract, link each benefit to your earlier pain points. For a first-generation MSP, the benefits often include:

  • Cost efficiency – consolidated supplier base, rate benchmarking, reduced rogue spend

  • Visibility and reporting – clear (and potentially real-time) data on workforce spend and performance metrics

  • Compliance and risk management – standardised contracts, reduced misclassification risk

  • Process efficiency – hiring manager time saved through centralised processes

  • Scalability: ability to flex workforce quickly in response to business needs

 

5. Consider the costs and change management

Decision-makers will naturally ask: “What will this cost us?” So, make sure you’re addressing the potential investment and disruption. Be transparent about:

  • Implementation fees or technology requirements (such as a Vendor Management System)

  • Internal resource required to manage the transition

  • Potential resistance from hiring managers or suppliers

Balance this with mitigation strategies (e.g., phased rollout, stakeholder engagement, supplier transition planning) to help strengthen your case.

 

6. Provide clear options 

Shifting your workforce strategy to a new one is a big change. And you may find executives will still be hesitant to commit. Rather than an “all or nothing” proposal, you might frame your case in a way that allows your decision makers to see the trade-offs more clearly:

  • Do nothing – maintain status quo (with quantified risks/costs)

  • Partial MSP – pilot in one region or business unit

  • Full MSP – organisation-wide implementation

 

7. Build your ROI model

The ROI doesn’t always have to be purely financial, but it helps to show hard numbers where possible. For example:

  • Forecasted cost savings through supplier rationalisation (e.g., 10–15%)

  • Reduction in time-to-hire (e.g., from 40 days to 25 days)

  • Reduction in compliance risks and potential fines

  • Hiring manager time saved (and the value of that time back to the business)

For example, organisations moving to a first-generation MSP often see 10–15% savings in year one through supplier consolidation alone.

Pair this data with qualitative outcomes such as improved candidate experience, better alignment with DEI goals, and stronger workforce planning.

 

8. Frame the narrative

Finally, package all of this into a clear, executive-friendly story. A structured narrative makes it easier for senior leaders to see the benefits and say "yes." A typical business case should flow like this:

  • The workforce challenges we face

  • Why it matters to the business

  • What a first-generation MSP could deliver

  • The options (and trade-offs) available

  • Costs, risks, and mitigations

  • The expected ROI and value-adds

  • The recommended next step

Building a business case for a first-generation MSP is ultimately about aligning your workforce strategy with long-term business goals. By framing the narrative this way, you help stakeholders see the benefits clearly and put yourself in the strongest position to secure buy-in.

When you’re ready to take the next step, think carefully about how you want your MSP delivered. Choosing the right MSP provider and the right MSP delivery model for your organisation will be key to ensuring a smooth transition and long-term success.

 

Share
Considering your first-generation MSP?

Visit our MSP solution page or book a discovery call to see how we can build a programme that supports your organisation's needs.

More like this

NEWS
Rullion strengthens ties across East Anglia with Ipswich office and Chamber membership

Rullion strengthens ties across East Anglia with Ipswich office and Chamber membership

Our involvement across East Anglia continues to grow. With investment and growth accelerating across the East of England, the opening of a new Ipswich office and our Suffolk Chamber of Commerce membership position us to play a more active role in supporting the region. Both milestones reflect our long-standing commitment to supporting local business growth and connecting people to meaningful work across the region. Located at 70–72 The Havens, Ransomes Europark, Ipswich, the new office is ideally positioned to serve clients and candidates across Suffolk and beyond. The site offers excellent access to the A14 and A12, with strong road and rail links to the Port of Felixstowe, East Anglia, and the Midlands – placing Rullion at the heart of one of the UK’s most active industrial and infrastructure hubs. Working together for a thriving East of England The East of England continues to see major investment in energy and infrastructure, including projects such as Sizewell C, which will create thousands of skilled jobs and strengthen the regional supply chain. Our Ipswich team is already helping local employers prepare for this demand by connecting them with skilled professionals and supporting workforce development initiatives. “Strengthening our ties across East Anglia has been a strategic objective this year. Our Ipswich office builds on years of partnership across the region and we’re proud to be part of the Suffolk Chamber of Commerce at such a pivotal time for the region. Sizewell C represents a huge opportunity – not only for the clean energy transition but for local people to develop skills and build lasting careers. By working collaboratively, we can help ensure Suffolk’s communities share in that success.” ~ John Armstrong, Build, Mechanical & Engineering Sector, Director Supporting clean energy and workforce growth Our recruitment teams are already helping businesses prepare for the skills demand created by Sizewell C. Through this partnership, we hope to contribute to Suffolk’s clean energy future and connect more people with the opportunities that come from investment in local infrastructure. Collaboration sits at the heart of Rullion’s approach. By joining the Suffolk Chamber of Commerce and establishing a stronger physical presence in Ipswich, we’re continuing to invest in the people, skills, and industries that will shape the region’s future. Together, we can help more people get work - and get work done.

By Rullion on 02 December 2025

A Guide to Careers in the Rail Industry

A Guide to Careers in the Rail Industry

If you’re thinking about a new career direction or wondering where your engineering or technical skills could take you, the rail industry is well worth a closer look. It’s one of the UK’s most stable sectors, it’s growing, and it’s going through one of the biggest modernisation periods in its history. Which makes it an ideal time to explore careers in the railway industry and wider rail sector. Is the rail industry a good career path? Yes. UK rail infrastructure quietly powers everything else in the UK. People rely on it. Businesses rely on it. And with investment flowing in from every direction, the demand for talent is only getting stronger. Why choose a career in rail? In 2025, the rail industry is in the middle of a major period of change. Large parts of the network are being upgraded, with old infrastructure being modernised and there’s a strong push towards a greener, more efficient rail system. That means a steady flow of railway career opportunities across engineering, operations, sustainability, project delivery, asset management, and more. And while some flagship programmes, like HS2, have been re-phased, the wider industry continues to move forward. Projects like Northern Powerhouse Rail, East West Rail, and Network Rail’s ongoing renewals and upgrades are still progressing at pace, creating sustained demand for skilled engineers, technicians, and project specialists. For anyone looking for job security and progression, careers in the rail industry offer both. What types of jobs are available in the UK rail industry? If you want a sector where you can actually grow, rail is a strong pick. One of the best things about rail is how broad it is. People often start in hands-on careers in the railway industry, maintenance, track, signalling, and operations and move into senior technical, project, or managerial roles over time. You’ll find roles in: Engineering and infrastructure: civil, mechanical, electrical, systems, signalling Operations: drivers, signallers, controllers, planners Maintenance: track operatives, technicians, asset inspectors Project delivery: project managers, planners, site supervisors Support and digital: procurement, IT, data, cyber, commercial roles What is the salary for railway jobs? Careers in the rail industry are generally well paid, and salaries often rise quickly with experience. Here’s a few common examples: Track/Maintenance Operatives: £28k–£38k Signalling Technicians: £35k–£50k Project Engineers: £40k–£55k Civil/Track Engineers: £45k–£65k Train Drivers: £55k–£70k Project Managers (Infrastructure): £55k–£75k (Sources: Network Rail, Glassdoor, and Prospects.ac.uk) What qualifications or skills do you need for a career in rail? The rail sector values both formal qualifications and on-the-job learning. Common routes include: NVQs or Level 3 qualifications in engineering, construction, or electrical work Apprenticeships with Network Rail, Transport for London, or major contractors Degrees in civil, mechanical, or electrical engineering for professional roles Sentinel training and safety certifications for operational work Deep dive into 'What is Sentinel and why do you need it?'. Just as important are the interpersonal and behavioural attributes that keep teams effective and safe: Strong communication and teamwork Problem-solving under pressure Attention to detail and adherence to safety protocols Adaptability, especially with new digital technologies How to get a job in the rail industry There isn’t one “right” way to start careers in the railway industry. A lot of people join through: Apprenticeships Graduate schemes Trainee technician routes Direct entry with trade experience (electrical, construction, mechanical) Via specialist transport recruitment agencies Working with a specialist agency can be especially helpful because you’ll get guidance on background checks, Sentinel training, and access to roles that aren’t always advertised publicly. Switching tracks into the rail industry Maybe you’re coming from construction, defence, automotive, energy, manufacturing, or even something completely different. Rail loves transferable skills. If you’ve got the foundations, organisations will often train you in the rail-specific parts. This is exactly how programmes like Train to Deploy work, taking experienced professionals, reskilling or upskilling them, and deploying them onto major rail projects. What background checks are needed for rail jobs? Because rail is a safety-critical environment, you’ll go through a few essential checks before you start working: Right-to-work and ID verification Reference/employment history checks Medical assessments Drug & alcohol screening DBS checks Sentinel competency verification if you’re working trackside Many employers use specialist background screening partners to speed things up and keep everything compliant. If you end up working with a rail & transport recruitment partner who understands the sector, they’ll usually guide you through the checks and help you get everything sorted without the stress. The future of railways There’s a very real buzz around the future of railways. As the rail network modernises, we’ll see more digital tools, better connectivity and a stronger focus on sustainability. All of which are creating new opportunities across engineering, operations and project delivery. The next decade is going to bring: Digital signalling and smarter control systems Greater automation Data-led maintenance More electrification and sustainability-focused projects Increased focus on diversity, accessibility and new talent pipelines All of this means long-term opportunity. If you want a career that lets you be part of something evolving and genuinely shaping the UK’s future, the rail industry is a brilliant place to be.

By Rullion on 20 November 2025